MIght gt a P5 tomorrow, have questions
November-16th-2001 | 05:47 PM
#31
Protege Newbie
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 37
sorry man, it's you
Originally posted by DBR
hi hitman, thanks for your thoughts, but i'd have to say i have a different opinion. i think there's something wrong with the protege driveline...CV joints, engine mounts, fuel delivery, ???? i'd say it's something in the gas peddle/throttle sensor/emission control/etc. i've driven about a dozen stick cars and half dozen motorcycles over the last 35 years, and none of them have had this problem except the protege. for example my other car is currently a hyundai accent (talk about low gearing!!!!!) and it doesn't rock anything like the protege.
i agree that the driver can stop the rocking by pushing in the clutch at the same time he takes his foot off the gas, but that seems like excessive coasting. (i failed my drivers license the first time for excessive coasting!!!)
i complained to mazda canada about this and they just sluffed me off.
it's interesting that it doesn't happen when the car is initially on a fast idle (1500 rpm), but starts as soon as the idle falls to normal (about 700 rpm).
anyway i'd appreciate it if you or anyone else has any theories about what causes the rocking and any solutions. does anyone know of any experienced protege tuners that might know? i called Racing Beat about 6 weeks ago, but they didn't recognize what i was talking about. i'd be prepared to pay a couple of thousand dollars to get it fixed since i'd lose that much in depreciation selling the car now, and i like the car except for this one thing. thanks again for your feedback.
hi hitman, thanks for your thoughts, but i'd have to say i have a different opinion. i think there's something wrong with the protege driveline...CV joints, engine mounts, fuel delivery, ???? i'd say it's something in the gas peddle/throttle sensor/emission control/etc. i've driven about a dozen stick cars and half dozen motorcycles over the last 35 years, and none of them have had this problem except the protege. for example my other car is currently a hyundai accent (talk about low gearing!!!!!) and it doesn't rock anything like the protege.
i agree that the driver can stop the rocking by pushing in the clutch at the same time he takes his foot off the gas, but that seems like excessive coasting. (i failed my drivers license the first time for excessive coasting!!!)
i complained to mazda canada about this and they just sluffed me off.
it's interesting that it doesn't happen when the car is initially on a fast idle (1500 rpm), but starts as soon as the idle falls to normal (about 700 rpm).
anyway i'd appreciate it if you or anyone else has any theories about what causes the rocking and any solutions. does anyone know of any experienced protege tuners that might know? i called Racing Beat about 6 weeks ago, but they didn't recognize what i was talking about. i'd be prepared to pay a couple of thousand dollars to get it fixed since i'd lose that much in depreciation selling the car now, and i like the car except for this one thing. thanks again for your feedback.
Honestly, try driving without shoes for a while. You'll probably notice right away that your being more aggressive with your throttle inputs than you thought you were. The worn (or just crappy) clutches on your former cars may have been masking this problem.
November-17th-2001 | 12:50 PM
#32
Thread Starter
Protege Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 80
From: St. Louis
Hate to agree with everyone but it is not the P5 drivetrain or anyhting like that. It usually tends to be the driver too. I haven't noticed it too much on my P5 and it isn't even a week old yet. I sit in about 20 minutes of rush hour on my way home each night and you just have to adjust your driving style to each new car. hate to say but i think it's the driver not the car
November-18th-2001 | 12:33 AM
#33
Protege Enthusiast
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 160
From: Cary, NC
I've been on a test driving frenzy here, while looking for the perfect protege5. Here's my views on the part throttle bucking.
I've driven the P5 a couple times and noticed the bucking. It's the same bucking that occurs with any car that has a quick throttle response. The solution is easy, just coast in 2nd gear instead of 1st. For a better solution practice being gentler on the accellerator pedal. But, you only really need 1st to get the car rolling anyway, so you can just use the easier method.
If you want to drive a car that does not do this go test drive a Focus ZX3. It doesn't do this at all, unless you make it do it. However, if you pay attention to the engine when you floor it, it takes a little longer for the engine to respond. The throttle response in the Focus isn't nearly as good as the P5.
My thoughts on it are that the engineers can design the throttle body in such a way to get rid of the low speed bucking. Doing this makes the car much easier to drive at slow speeds. The side effect of it is that you lose throttle response, by having a throttle body that doesn't react as quickly and only allows the engine to see small changes at a time. This sucks while driving aggressively. If you don't agree then go visit some of the Focus boards and pay attention to all of the people complaining about the throttle response of their cars.
Jason
I've driven the P5 a couple times and noticed the bucking. It's the same bucking that occurs with any car that has a quick throttle response. The solution is easy, just coast in 2nd gear instead of 1st. For a better solution practice being gentler on the accellerator pedal. But, you only really need 1st to get the car rolling anyway, so you can just use the easier method.
If you want to drive a car that does not do this go test drive a Focus ZX3. It doesn't do this at all, unless you make it do it. However, if you pay attention to the engine when you floor it, it takes a little longer for the engine to respond. The throttle response in the Focus isn't nearly as good as the P5.
My thoughts on it are that the engineers can design the throttle body in such a way to get rid of the low speed bucking. Doing this makes the car much easier to drive at slow speeds. The side effect of it is that you lose throttle response, by having a throttle body that doesn't react as quickly and only allows the engine to see small changes at a time. This sucks while driving aggressively. If you don't agree then go visit some of the Focus boards and pay attention to all of the people complaining about the throttle response of their cars.
Jason
February-8th-2002 | 12:36 AM
#38
Registered User
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 1,030
From: ottawa, ontario canada
pro's about the car
LOOKS!!!!!......i even find myself stairing at it for a good 30's each time i look at my car
HANDELING!......i like the fact that i can take off ramps at twice the speed
interior is nicely layed out
cons
stock CD player is $hit.......replaced it with a 1700 one
car is very low to the ground, which sucks for us canadians, means i actualy have to shovel the snow in my driveway
car is a tad under powered....i'm being picky though, its much better then my buddies POS 97 caveillier
car seems harder to start in the -20 temps (but has always turned over!!!) get a block heater!
tight suspention give you a bit of a bumpy ride, may not like that
but the pro's definatly out way the cons!....i love my pro5
LOOKS!!!!!......i even find myself stairing at it for a good 30's each time i look at my car
HANDELING!......i like the fact that i can take off ramps at twice the speed
interior is nicely layed out
cons
stock CD player is $hit.......replaced it with a 1700 one
car is very low to the ground, which sucks for us canadians, means i actualy have to shovel the snow in my driveway
car is a tad under powered....i'm being picky though, its much better then my buddies POS 97 caveillier
car seems harder to start in the -20 temps (but has always turned over!!!) get a block heater!
tight suspention give you a bit of a bumpy ride, may not like that
but the pro's definatly out way the cons!....i love my pro5
February-8th-2002 | 02:05 AM
#39
Not slow, hp challenged
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 180
From: Las Vegas, NV
Originally posted by nightowl
pro's about the car
LOOKS!!!!!......i even find myself stairing at it for a good 30's each time i look at my car
pro's about the car
LOOKS!!!!!......i even find myself stairing at it for a good 30's each time i look at my car
February-8th-2002 | 07:09 PM
#41
Master of All Things :{D
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 4,118
From: southeast texas, near houston
well that last post got away from me!! ha ha ha
do not hesitate...the P-5 is killer.......its the best looking car in its class bar NONE, handles like a dream, and although I have heard many people say its underpowered....well I guess they are just use to driving big V-8's or something...the P-5 has plenty of ZIP even at highway speeds......and just look at all the imitators starting to hit the market.....there is quite a list, however NONE of them have as much personality as the P-5. When I had our two at the tint shop, and they were parked out front after getting tinted, there were guys from the local GM dealer stopping in and asking the tint shop guys what they were.....they are ture attention getters. As I said...our two P-5's....I got my wife a Black one...and mine is vivid yellow. I just couldn't see getting one and letting HER have all the fun! :{D
Hope you get your ride...and have as much fun with it as I am having with MINE!!!!
do not hesitate...the P-5 is killer.......its the best looking car in its class bar NONE, handles like a dream, and although I have heard many people say its underpowered....well I guess they are just use to driving big V-8's or something...the P-5 has plenty of ZIP even at highway speeds......and just look at all the imitators starting to hit the market.....there is quite a list, however NONE of them have as much personality as the P-5. When I had our two at the tint shop, and they were parked out front after getting tinted, there were guys from the local GM dealer stopping in and asking the tint shop guys what they were.....they are ture attention getters. As I said...our two P-5's....I got my wife a Black one...and mine is vivid yellow. I just couldn't see getting one and letting HER have all the fun! :{D
Hope you get your ride...and have as much fun with it as I am having with MINE!!!!
February-9th-2002 | 09:35 AM
#42
Indecisive Protege Owner Wannabie
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 220
Originally posted by Sir Nuke
well that last post got away from me!! ha ha ha
do not hesitate...the P-5 is killer.......its the best looking car in its class bar NONE, handles like a dream, and although I have heard many people say its underpowered....well I guess they are just use to driving big V-8's or something...the P-5 has plenty of ZIP even at highway speeds......and just look at all the imitators starting to hit the market.....there is quite a list, however NONE of them have as much personality as the P-5. When I had our two at the tint shop, and they were parked out front after getting tinted, there were guys from the local GM dealer stopping in and asking the tint shop guys what they were.....they are ture attention getters. As I said...our two P-5's....I got my wife a Black one...and mine is vivid yellow. I just couldn't see getting one and letting HER have all the fun! :{D
Hope you get your ride...and have as much fun with it as I am having with MINE!!!!
well that last post got away from me!! ha ha ha
do not hesitate...the P-5 is killer.......its the best looking car in its class bar NONE, handles like a dream, and although I have heard many people say its underpowered....well I guess they are just use to driving big V-8's or something...the P-5 has plenty of ZIP even at highway speeds......and just look at all the imitators starting to hit the market.....there is quite a list, however NONE of them have as much personality as the P-5. When I had our two at the tint shop, and they were parked out front after getting tinted, there were guys from the local GM dealer stopping in and asking the tint shop guys what they were.....they are ture attention getters. As I said...our two P-5's....I got my wife a Black one...and mine is vivid yellow. I just couldn't see getting one and letting HER have all the fun! :{D
Hope you get your ride...and have as much fun with it as I am having with MINE!!!!
February-9th-2002 | 11:25 AM
#43
Master of All Things :{D
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 4,118
From: southeast texas, near houston
YEP!! TWO!! for if I were to have only gotten ONE....then my wife would be driving it all the time and I would be stuck in my old work truck....and what fun would that be....a few weeks before I got them....my wife made the comment to me while we were driving in my truck that I should think about getting ME something to play with after we got the new car....she thought I would get a "project" car seeing as how that is a hobby of mine....but I wanted INSTANT fun....and what better way then to just get me my very own P-5......she didn't even know I got two till we went down to pick them up! what a surprised look was on her face...it was priceless. :{D
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Rob13
3rd Gen Protege/MazdaSpeed/P5/MP3
7
July-5th-2002 02:24 AM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)