Strut tower bar question

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old June-2nd-2002 | 01:09 AM
  #1  
Aaron's Avatar
Thread Starter
Registered User
 
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 250
From: IA
Aaron is on a distinguished road
Question Strut tower bar question

sorry is this is a dumb one, but what will adding the strut tower bar(mp3 bar) do? the brochure says it adds crispness to the steering but what does that mean exactly?
Old June-2nd-2002 | 02:16 AM
  #2  
Sir Nuke's Avatar
Master of All Things :{D
 
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 4,118
From: southeast texas, near houston
Sir Nuke is on a distinguished road
what it does...is it connects the tops of your strut towers together...it gives stiffness to the body....so that it doesn't flex as much...which transmitts presure from one side of the car to the other...
Old June-2nd-2002 | 05:21 AM
  #3  
Pro_fan's Avatar
Bruce Leroy
 
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 788
From: Calgary, AB, Canada
Pro_fan is on a distinguished road
As I understand it, when you enter a corner hard, much of the car's weight is transferred to the opposite side of the car that you are turning towards (ie. making a left turn, weight is transferred to the right side of the car). If you enter hard enough, you will lose traction due to the decreased weight on the wheel.

So basically, the strut bar makes that car stay in contact with the ground, thereby providing more traction at all the wheels, which in turn lets you corner harder and faster.

Hmmm...Now that I read the Nuke's post again, Nuke basically said this, but I'll post this anyway just to make the idea a little more explicit.

Last edited by Pro_fan; June-11th-2002 at 01:06 AM.
Old June-2nd-2002 | 01:34 PM
  #4  
Aaron's Avatar
Thread Starter
Registered User
 
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 250
From: IA
Aaron is on a distinguished road
is this something a schmuck could install or do i need to let the dealer put it on?
Old June-2nd-2002 | 03:47 PM
  #5  
Sir Nuke's Avatar
Master of All Things :{D
 
Joined: Feb 2002
Posts: 4,118
From: southeast texas, near houston
Sir Nuke is on a distinguished road
Originally posted by Aaron
is this something a schmuck could install or do i need to let the dealer put it on?
if you know how to operate a combination wrench or a socket wrench....YOU can put it on yourself...its a piece of cake....

get the part from the dealer...or where ever....then go by a dealer and have them lift the hood on any P-5, since there will be plenty of them there...and look where its installed and how....you will see how simple it is to put on.....then go for it. :{D
Old June-2nd-2002 | 05:59 PM
  #6  
carguycw's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 1,122
From: Dallas, Texas
carguycw is on a distinguished road
Originally posted by Pro_fan
As I understand it, when you enter a corner hard, much of the car's weight is transferred to the side of the car that you are turning towards (ie. making a left turn, weight is transferred to the left side of the car). If you enter hard enough, you will lose traction on the opposite side due to the decreased pressure on that wheel.

So basically, the strut bar makes that opposite side stay in contact with the ground, thereby providing more traction at all the wheels, which in turn lets you corner harder and faster.
This is a better description of a swaybar than a strut brace. Strut braces prevent body flex, which makes the steering more precise because the car's wheels are held in tighter alignment.

Strut braces mainly benefit cars with really flexible unibodies, such as a Datsun 240Z, AE86 Toyota Corolla, or Fox3 Mustang. Strut braces don't usually do a whole lot on a car with a reasonably strong body structure (like a 99+ Protege). They have a small effect on traction, but the effect on a Protege will be pretty minimal compared to the other parts of the suspension, such as the springs, swaybars, shocks, bushings and tires.

IMHO a strut brace for the front of a BJ Pro belongs on the "Do This Last" list, not the "Do This First" list. YMMV
Old June-2nd-2002 | 06:44 PM
  #7  
Aaron's Avatar
Thread Starter
Registered User
 
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 250
From: IA
Aaron is on a distinguished road
thanks fellas
Old June-10th-2002 | 02:14 PM
  #8  
Eric F's Avatar
Protege God
 
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 1,525
From: Evanston, IL
Eric F is on a distinguished road
Did I miss something? When you turn left, weight is transferred to the right side of the car, and vice versa. An anti sway bar ties the two sides of the suspension together to resist this weight transfer and therefore reduces body lean. The strut tower bar does exactly what Chris said, it prevents flex and holds the alignment better.
I did notice a difference in my '00 ES when I added the strut tower bar however, and I would recommend one for the 3rd gens. I would get an inexpesive one though, as I don't think the more expensive ones provide much additional benefit.


Originally posted by carguycw


This is a better description of a swaybar than a strut brace. Strut braces prevent body flex, which makes the steering more precise because the car's wheels are held in tighter alignment.

Strut braces mainly benefit cars with really flexible unibodies, such as a Datsun 240Z, AE86 Toyota Corolla, or Fox3 Mustang. Strut braces don't usually do a whole lot on a car with a reasonably strong body structure (like a 99+ Protege). They have a small effect on traction, but the effect on a Protege will be pretty minimal compared to the other parts of the suspension, such as the springs, swaybars, shocks, bushings and tires.

IMHO a strut brace for the front of a BJ Pro belongs on the "Do This Last" list, not the "Do This First" list. YMMV
Old June-10th-2002 | 03:47 PM
  #9  
macdaddyslomo's Avatar
Moderator/ Pocket Tuner
 
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 4,150
From: Tampa,Fl
macdaddyslomo is on a distinguished road
a strut tower bar is a good investment....you will notice a quicker steering response,especially on hard cornering or a hard high speed lane change....a strut bar will stiffen the chassis and also help the anti sway bar in sharing the load under a hard corner....think of it like this...even with the anti sway bar...you have 2 strut towers
! ! ...under a hard corner with no strut bar,1 strut tower bears most of the load ! /....the strut tower bar ties the 2 struts together equalizing the load in the hard corner / /...the symbols i put demonstrate how the strut towers flex under load
Old June-10th-2002 | 04:52 PM
  #10  
Eric F's Avatar
Protege God
 
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 1,525
From: Evanston, IL
Eric F is on a distinguished road
Huh??? However you understand it best is fine, but the way you're explaining it seems likely to confuse other people trying to understand what the two different bars do.
For example, adding a strut tower bar will not reduce body roll in a corner. The strut tower bar bolts to the sheet metal strut tower mounts on each side of the car only. The strut tower bar has nothing to do with the suspension directly. Any improvements by a strut tower bar are indirect, and a result of stiffening the chassis at the upper points the suspension mounts to it. This does improve steering response by reducing flex which makes the car respond faster since chassis flex takes time. It also improves suspension alignment which makes handling more consistent, again due to reduced chassis flex.
A stabilizer bar (anti sway bar) mounts to each side of the sub frame, and to each side of the suspension either at the strut or control arm depending on the vehicle. The sub frame position is fixed, therefore, so are the stabilizer bar mounting points on the sub frame. The ends of the stabilizer bar are mounted to the suspension on opposite sides of the car. So when taking a corner one side of the suspension wants to compress because of the additional weight being shifted on it, while the other side wants to extend because of the weight being shifted away from it. The stabilizer bar resists this by being twisted like a torsion spring since it is mounted to both sides of the suspension AND the sub frame. Without all four of these mounting points, a bar cannot resist weight transfer (body roll).


Originally posted by macdaddyslomo
a strut tower bar is a good investment....you will notice a quicker steering response,especially on hard cornering or a hard high speed lane change....a strut bar will stiffen the chassis and also help the anti sway bar in sharing the load under a hard corner....think of it like this...even with the anti sway bar...you have 2 strut towers
! ! ...under a hard corner with no strut bar,1 strut tower bears most of the load ! /....the strut tower bar ties the 2 struts together equalizing the load in the hard corner / /...the symbols i put demonstrate how the strut towers flex under load
Old June-14th-2002 | 04:21 AM
  #11  
born2zoom's Avatar
Protege Newbie
 
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 37
From: Vancouver, BC
born2zoom is on a distinguished road
Does adding a strut bar really that much of a difference? Can you notice it if someone installed it without you knowing?!
Old June-14th-2002 | 10:04 AM
  #12  
proman's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 336
From: Buffalo NY
proman is on a distinguished road
I have one on and i don't feel much difference unless i take hard turns. I can't wait till the next autocross to test it ou though. that's where you'll be able to tell the difference. the only thing is that it will put me out of h-stock so we'll see.
Old June-18th-2002 | 09:53 PM
  #13  
kc5zom's Avatar
Certified Sick Individual
 
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 1,141
From: Houston, TX.
kc5zom is on a distinguished road
Gonna agree with Proman there. Its nice but no big deal. I just wanted my steering to be a little more enjoyable, which it now is. Plus it was really easy to put in, if you get the right parts, and adds some show-off value as well there.
Old June-19th-2002 | 11:52 AM
  #14  
Eric F's Avatar
Protege God
 
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 1,525
From: Evanston, IL
Eric F is on a distinguished road
It's hard to say. How noticable it is depends on the individual. The steering response change was noticable to me. For it's ease of installation, and low cost, I think it's worth it. Depending on how much or cars chassis' flex, it can have benefits that you don't feel directly also. Such as maintaning better alignment due to reduced chassis flex.
Related Topics
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
mixmaster_matt
3rd gen Suspension/Brakes
1
April-24th-2003 01:01 AM
LOS-323
3rd gen Suspension/Brakes
1
December-26th-2002 03:02 PM
MarkSpark
Exterior/Interior/Audio
3
December-22nd-2002 06:46 PM
Nancys ES
3rd gen Suspension/Brakes
3
December-20th-2002 11:16 AM
MarkSpark
3rd gen Suspension/Brakes
14
October-20th-2002 09:34 PM

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:32 PM.