You can always get in touch with onlinemazdaparts.com and see what the part would cost from the factory. As far as I know all the ones in the States were painted so you should be able to source it. That should be cheaper than having yours painted.

Millennium Red. :)

Definitely red. Black would scream "civic dx" to me.

Yeh, I thought so too. It's just that black would have cost much less than color matching it to the car.

Do you think if I duplicolor it Millennium Red, it would turn out OK, or look like crap?

Sand, prime, paint, and clear. With multiple coats and a bit of love it will look good! :)

I'll try it, worst I can do is F' it up and have to bring it to a paint shop afterwards, haha.